The Scott Specialized catalog is a very simplified catalog when it comes to postal stationery. If you want to go deeply into these, I would recommend finding a copy of the "Catalog of the 20th Century Stamped Envelopes and Wrappers of the United States" published by the United Postal Stationery Society.
https://www.upss.org/This UPSS catalog illustrates approximately 150 varieties of this design, so it is highly likely your stamp will be one of these, rather than an error.
That said, it would be useful to us if you could post a enlarged scan of the embossed area.