Is it any wonder that new collectors get confused by the 'experts' here? You guys go off in the weeds on trying to debate each other while the new collector is listing stamps as 'RARE' and asking totally unrealistic prices.
I do not think the below stamps were posted in the SCF such that she could be " confused by the 'experts' here" prior to setting her prices.
Elsewhere on SCF, you, Don bemoaned the disruption to the hobby for new comers when they see the "generous" and unrealistic pricing of stamps on eBay.
Here the OP asked if something was "rare" and I answered by the book, the dictionary book. What the OP really wants to know is not about rarity, but value as in what is it worth, without specifying if selling to an experienced collector or a common P.T. Barnum rube.
Also I will clearly point out the OP is a baldfaced liar, denying that this was the same stamp shown in here prior thread. When I brought over the photo for comparison, she stopped posting in this thread. So if the so-called experts here are out in the weeds, were exactly do the liars stand?