Using this old post because I am puzzled about the same thing. I cannot for the life of me figure out what counts as toned paper or not. I can see the difference in shading in the first picture (2:15 PM), but the difference doesn't seem like something that couldn't happen because old stamps can age. And I don't see the difference at all in the 3:19 PM post.
I have a #59, which is described in the catalog as only being produced on toned paper. I also have a #48, which is not listed as being on toned paper (other stamps in the set are). The #59 and the #48 look like they are identical shades of paper to me. (Of course, they are obviously discolored by age and maybe some dirt as well.)
