Quote:
I assume, then, that examples with actual writing in the required fields MUST be valid use?
I would generalize that there are 2 broad categories of these:
1. Those fully issued to an end user with a user name, city, date, etc., and which would have no punches as they were in the hands of the user and never part of the Deats/Sterling salvage. Most of these would have been discarded after they expired.
2. The punched remainders, which may fall into 2 sub-categories: 2a, the fully mint examples; and 2b, where for convenience, many local officials pre-signed the tax stamps which were never actually completed with a taxpayer's name, date, etc., and subsequently punched, which is what I believe you may be seeing if you look closely.
And yes, there are a very small number which would not fall neatly into these groupings (such as a form made-out in error, voided, and left in the form book and a corrected stamp issued).
Add: some of the revenue agents were noteworthy civil war officers, creating interest among autograph collectors.