As a nearly 50-year teacher of history, the Boston vs. Philadelphia debate here is interesting, but I'm afraid Boston wins pretty clearly in a celebration of 250 years since 1776.
Nearly every major event and most major developments leading to the American Revolution occurred in the Boston area -- except the Second Continental Congress which drafted the Declaration of Independence. That document was not at all the beginning but the culmination of the drive for American independence much of which happened in Boston. Boston began the Revolution with its street mobs, burning effigies, attacks on the stamp tax men, protest marches and protest meetings and its firing the first shots in both the Boston Massacre (1770) and at Lexington and Concord (1775) where professional British troops from Boston were battled to a standstill by ordinary American farmers. It's pretty much all Boston up the that point.
The meeting in Philadelphia had little to do with pre-revolutionary events there since there had been few, if any, and was far more due to its central location so delegates from all the colonies could get there -- and the fact that, at that time, Philadelphia was the largest city in the colonies. And maybe also to avoid Boston mobs and patriot troublemakers!
The Centennial Exposition held in Philadelphia in 1876 was because the Declaration and the U.S. Constitution were both written there, but oddly it chose 1776 as the founding date of the country -- which it wasn't. This is a popular historical confusion most people seem to suffer from. Just to be clear, the 1776 Declaration of Independence did not set up any government. It simply declared our independence and listed a lot of reasons why we deserved it (taxation, troops, home invasions, and so on). We still needed to create a government -- which we did later. So it's a question or whether or not you are celebrating the Revolution and independence or the legal foundations of the American Republic, and I think the show was to honor the former, not the latter.
If USA 250 were about the legal foundations of this country that were written down in Philadelphia you'd expect it to be held in 2037 (the Constitution was written in 1787) or in 2038 (1788 was the year nine states finally ratified it, the number required) or in 2039 (1789 was the year it went into effect). But it wasn't because none of these events align with the popular imagination about the earlier Revolution and independence. History proves that if the people believe something, even if it's not true, you are stuck with it! |