I agree with the commentator who noted that any stamps people now think are worth getting are likely in the long run not to appreciate that much. So although I do collect the panes of 4 of Priority Mail and Priority Mail Express stamps, I know they may not appreciate that well. Just do a search on
ebay and you will find multiple listings of these. The main thing going for the PM and PM stamps is the production for each is relatively low - 1 - 5 million. And the USPS gets rids of any unsold stock (as they do with commemoratives).
Here are some stamps that have promise of attaining a good premium in the future - note I say PROMISE, not guarantee:
a) USED Priority Mail Express stamps. Most people get meter strips and do not use them unless they are providing a SASE Priority Mail Express envelope within their mailing. Yes occasionally there is usage than other what I just wrote. The use of PME and even PM diminish as we get into the American Landmark series of such stamps (about 2010).
b) Imperforate commemoratives of recent times may or may not do well, it depends how long the USPS has them for sale. USED modern imperforates I find a bit scarce - I have only one in my collection and often they are from stamp dealers, collectors and clubs. Those imperforates used without any philatelic association would be especially scarce or possibly rare.
c) 2020 Stamp Yearbook is deemed scarce as the USPS produced only 13,000 of they went off-sale quickly.
d) As has been mentioned, certain definitive coils may be scarce depending on their plate number. I believe the Waving Flags of 2022 from Ashton Potter with plate P2 is one such example. There is a scarce plate number in the 2 cent Navajo Jewelry stamp issues, and the Transportation coil series has a few scarce or even rare plate numbers.
e) Having a complete series does help add value to stamps. The Nature In America set while not really having that much of a premium individually as a complete set would be more attractive than an individual issue to a budding stamp collector.
f) Limited Editions sets with proofs provided MIGHT have a chance of accruing a future premium. The most recent one is the Endangered Species set which is limited to 4,000. They are still on sale at USPS. If you shop carefully you can get these from USPS but I would avoid portfolio sets because there is no production limit - unless you are very interested in the topic as they are informative (and I would recommend the Go For Broke set and Civil War but realize these may not be good investment vehicles).