I agree with the previous answers, this is 220. The "thumbprint" is the postal cancel, not a thumbprint. Value is nominal.
To clarify the catalog numbers in the original post, your choices are 219D (lake) or 220 (shades of carmine and rose). It is not 219, which is a blue 1 cent stamp.
Although scanned images for purposes of color ID have drawbacks due to scanner and screen variability, here are 219D and 220 scanned together from dated covers. The top is 219D, postmarked April 22, 1890 (although 220 was available by then, this is the earlier lake shade), and on the bottom is 220 postmarked in July 1890. Yours is clearly the later shade.
