Quote:
Why not put a dummy character in front. For regular stamps us R123 for airmail use AM112 etc.
That would still require a license because you are still basing your ID on the Scott numbering system.
Quote:
The Mystic U.S. Stamp Catalog doesn't seem to have a problem with using Scott numbers. Perhaps a fee is involved.
Yes, Mystic, Brookman, Unitrade, USPS, Black Book, StampManage... all pay a licensing fee to Amos.
Quote:
Just of out curiosity, is one allowed to have an online website that sells stamps and use Scott catalog numbers without having to ask for copyright permission? I'm just wondering how much fair use is allowed in these kinds of circumstances?
In the introduction, Scott gives conditions under which Scott numbers may be used. Two of the terms for which permission is granted are:
Quote:
b) Such use is incidental to the business of buying and selling stamps and is limited in scope and length, i.e., it does not cover a substantial portion of the total number of stamps issued by any country or of any special category of stamps of any country; and
c) Such material is not used as part of any catalogue, stamp album or computerized or other system based upon the Scott catalogue numbers, or in any updated valuations of stamps not offered for sale or purchase;
There are other conditions of course. Check your Scott catalog Table of Contents page. I only typed 2 terms to give you all a rough idea.
I can fully understand the need to protect intellectual property. I don't understand the need to shoot yourself in the foot in the process.
Posted 08/13/2010 10:01 pm
