Looks quite genuine.
http://www.stampsmarter.com/feature...ViewAll.htmlhas this listed as from Naperville, IL. There is a category "Masks" that made the search easy enough. Nice to get this on a Columbian!
While that reference covers the banknotes era, there were a lot of cancels listed that were used before the 1870-94 time period and a fair number used well after that. So it's worth checking it out for those. The 20th Century database hopes to list whatever was used 1894 to date; a few of these old ones were reused up until the 1930s, at least.