The 2 posts show handstamps which are mechanically different.
The 1952 RPO device is much newer and has a handle which unscrews so that the date slugs are inserted from the back side into individual slots. The slugs have a lip to stop them from falling out the front when inserting them. The handle screws on and holds everything in place during use. The year date would almost certainly be inserted correctly at the beginning of the year and only removed periodically for cleaning.
The 3 devices Don shows use slugs inserted from the front (from the printing side) and held in place by the set screw. It is easy for all the slugs to frequently fall out when changing the AM/PM or day slug. Inverts would be fairly common - as would having the time, month, day, year slugs in different orders from day to day. They are also much older devices. I would expect the Toronto device to be of this general construction for holding the dating slugs.
As a tangent, occasionally the set screw stops just right to take ink and gets rocked a bit during canceling to imprint on the mail piece!
