Mdroth, I have in my defence only been an scf member for 7mths. Have only used the stampsmarter website a couple of times and was totaly unaware of the revue page. It is under "buying online" and have now found it by hitting that button for the very first time today. I used the link Don gave yesterday to go to the revue page and learned of its existance.
Generally I end up on the library page and sift through a few things and never used the buying online page as I have not bought anything online from any unknown person or from
ebay stamps for years.
And generally I note that most SCF members post items and sellers and discuss them on the boards all the time. And I see as you mention that almost no one is putting anything up on that review page. Obviously, they are unaware and or it may be that some people may not want to be vocal, for fear of retaliation or being flamed.
As a suggestion only, to Don and crew if it is not overly burdening, maybe a link button to the review page could be put in the library about buying,selling, and reviews.
Obviously there are many, like myself, who are not fully aware of everything available on that site or have not been able to completly review all of its great content.
Mike