The imperf stamp is almost certainly a late(r) printing from either Plate 2L or 5L. I am thinking an 1857 printing. Quite a bit of plate wear exhibited, and those inner framelines being as faint as they are a good indicator of a late-state plate.
Rls, the white area that Chase is referring to is the damaged relief area of the A-relief on the 6-relief transfer roll used for the 1857-61 stamps. The white areas were retouched by hand directly on the plate. The retouching resulted in some of the most interesting of all the three cent stamps. Here is a very rare example from Plate 12. It has only one of the areas "repaired". This stamp also holds the spot as the earliest known use of a Plate 12 stamp.
