To build on stallzer's excellent reply, canceling machines often had a machine number in the dial or killer. The example stallzer shows is an International machine. Yours is from a Barry machine, like these:

Yes, when the machine number hits the stamp it can cause some confusion. Soaked stamps often lose the context of the full cancel. Here is a tightly cropped version from a cover included in the scan above. It looks like a re-value at first, but it is only the machine number!

Here is a page of numbers from an old collector's stockbook. There is a page of alphabet letter cancels too. Fun stuff!
