
Stamp on left is, I believe, SC 12, 1857, smooth white paper, unwatermarked. On the right is what appears to be SC 9, 1856, rough yellowish paper, watermark 105(crossed diagonal lines).
The two are of the same design type but, by comparison, the one on the right looks suspicious. Yet it is on the rough yellowish paper and has the watermark of crossed lines.

So, is it genuine after all?