Eacles Best Or Eagles Best

Jim Drummond illustrated an example of this facsimile label in this thread:
https://goscf.com/t/53621&whichpage...Terms=eacles

I recently picked up a collection of what was described as "weird stuff".

In this batch I found examples of this facsimile (and a facsimile of a facsimile?)




In addition to the minor differences including the words NEW YORK in larger type on the Eacles example, the eagles nest appears to be different.

Eacles example:


Eagles example:


Also, the Eacles printing is nice and sharp, with a smooth feel to the printing (lithographed?)

The Eagles example is much more rough and broken up with an engraved feel to the printing.

There were 2 examples of each and 3 of the four have red threads on the paper. I don't believe they were part of the printing as they are laying on top of the paper and not embedded.

Both are similar to the Lanman & Kemp private die perfume stamps, RT16-RT18.

I think the vignette is a phoenix, rising from the flames.