Tom, a cancelled verses a mint plate number single may or may not be more valuable. Again, it depends on other factors, not just the plate number attachment. Some cancelled, scarce stamps, are worth more than their mint counter-part. That could hold true to that particular issue being more valuable with the plate number attached.
It seems there are always variables to deal with, not the least being how one preceives value. I tend to value plate numbered stamps more just because I like them.
