That damage/stain spot looks like the ultramarine ink had been bleached or sun faded, lines of ink are still present.
The Error of Color 4 cent Colunbian is, as has been mentioned, more the color of the 1 cent Columbian.....
from the
U.S. Philatelic Classics Society 1987
Chronicle: 138
"While printed with ink using the same Prussian blue colorant, the 4¢
error is not exactly the same blue as the I¢ Columbian."
and
Chronicle 135
""One-cent. - ' Co lumbus in Sight of Land ,' after the painting by Wm . H. Powell ," and
"Color, Antwerp blue ."
The two shades that revcollector mentioned?
Here's the 1 cent Columbian for comparison.
