It's plate 191.

Leftmost shows an earlier Penny Red without inscribed number to show the white dashes in the diamonds. Their position is the same on every stamp.
The middle is position KK showing that dash in the diamond. There's a definite "1" in the diamond.
The rightmost is the subject stamp. Again, compare positions of dashes. Parts of the cancel covers enough spots to make the white parts looks like a "3", though not exactly to me.