EMaxim: thanks for posting about this book. I also recently bought a copy, from a surplus book sale at Rocky Mountain Philatelic Library, but have not had time yet to review it (yes, I'll put in another "shameless plug" for the library).
You also wrote: "the frustration I felt when Scott and other catalogues say 'counterfeits about,' but give no hint how to recognize them." I shared your frustration in years past. Perhaps such details are not part of what a general catalogue is supposed to do.
But, as I began to specialize in several countries, up to 30 years ago, I sought out the resources available through various specialist societies; not just their and other web sites, but also print publications. As examples, I've found these publications to be highly useful. And I have others:
1) "Forgeries of Portugal and Colonies," by the late D,J. Davies 2) "A Catalogue of the Stamps of Mexico, 1856-1910," by Nicholas Follansbee.
I've also found the Serrane Guide, published by the APS, to be a marvelous resource. Even Serrane says, in places, "you have to do comparisons." But doesn't give examples. Nothing is perfect. |