Quote:
What Should I Do Next
Pause for a bit.
As Rod states correctly, your images show that your stamp is not aligned with the correct gauge line. This gives you a faulty reading and an incorrect ID. To build on his reply, taking your image "3 of 8", I have cropped it and added notations:

Line 1 goes through a dot on the gauge and through the center of a
perf hole on your stamp.
Line 2 goes through a dot on the gauge and through the center of a
perf tooth on your stamp.
Correct gauging would have the same alignment across the entire row of dots.
Your stamp is not perf 11 at the side, thus it cannot be a 554 or any variety of it. Looking further...
The printed image of your stamp is approximately 2cm high, which is the span of the perf gauge. Since the side perforations of your stamp is "off-alignment" by about a half a perf from the "11" line, it indicates that it should align extremely well with the 10.5 line on your gauge. Your stamp can only be a Scott 634, perf 11 at top/bottom and perf 10.5 at the sides.
Lastly, it would be good practice to acquire a good pair of tongs to minimize handing your stamps directly with your hands, which transfer oils to the stamps, leave fingerprints, etc.