Yes, the 'thrill' of the hunt can be fun. But to get the most productive input it is best to follow a few simple steps.
Rare stamps are just that; rare. Always assume that you have the most common stamps then work your way through the process of elimination. Start with the stamp design, then perforations, then watermarks. This will usually eliminate the majority of the 'rare' stamps. Leave color and measurements as the very last step. Dimensions you find in catalogs and online are estimates and the margin of error in measuring can be significant. It is best to make a template out of other (cheaper or damaged) stamps to compare with.
Also dig into as much education as you can get. Get specialize catalog for your area of interest. If you like US stamps consider Stamp Smarter website (
http://www.stampsmarter.com/).
Don
APS #094826