Keep in mind one of the fundamental rules of IDing stamps: whatever is written on the back of the stamp could be wrong.
And not just because somebody might have misIDed the stamp. On occasion (although rare), Die/Type definitions differ among the different catalogs. And (very rarely) the definitions can change/evolve over the years -- just like catalog numbers get renumbered.
It's always encouraging to see our personal ID effort match what is written on the back, but don't be surprised if every once in awhile it doesn't.

k